Home/Store/Cookie Recipes
Butterfinger Cookie Recipe
+2

Butterfinger Cookie Recipe

C$5.99
New Fall 2026
Instant Digital Download
In stock
Product Details

If you love chocolate and peanut butter, the Butterfinger Cookie is calling your name.

This thick, bakery-style brown sugar cookie is packed with chopped Butterfinger pieces throughout, then finished with a milk chocolate drizzle and even more Butterfinger on top.

Sweet, crunchy, chocolatey, and loaded with that unmistakable Butterfinger flavour, this one is made to stand out on a market table or satisfy a serious candy-bar craving.

This digital recipe includes measurements in both cups and grams, along with full step-by-step instructions.

Please note: This is a digital download only. No physical product will be shipped.

Show More
Save this product for later
Share this product with your friends
ShareSharePin it
Butterfinger Cookie Recipe
You May Also Like
BEST SELLER
The OG Cookie Recipe Bundle
The OG Cookie Recipe Bundle
The OG Cookie Recipe Bundle
Instant Digital Download
C$59.99
  • My Account
  • Track Orders
  • Favorites
  • Shopping Bag
Display prices in:CAD
Skip to main content
Baked by the Lake
Digital Recipes
About
Contact Us
My Favourite Tools & Products
Menu
Baked by the Lake
Terms & ConditionsReport Abuse
Powered by Lightspeed