Home/Store/Cookie Recipes
Stuffed Peanut Butter Marshmallow Cookie
+3
+2

Stuffed Peanut Butter Marshmallow Cookie

C$5.99
NEW
Instant Digital Download
In stock
Product Details

A nostalgic prairie classic—turned cookie.
If you're from Northwestern Ontario or Manitoba, chances are you've had a Peanut Butter Marshmallow Square at every potluck, shower, or holiday table. It's a staple recipe around here—and after dreaming of cookie-fying it for years, that vision has finally come to life!

These ultra-soft cookies are stuffed with a gooey square of the iconic treat and topped with a swirl of the same butterscotch-marshmallow goodness. It’s sweet, salty, chewy, and ridiculously addictive. A true hometown classic with a Baked by the Lake twist.

Each digital recipe includes:

  • Clear step-by-step instructions
  • Detailed ingredient measurements (imperial and metric)
  • Helpful baking tips for guaranteed success
Show More
Save this product for later
Share this product with your friends
ShareSharePin it
Stuffed Peanut Butter Marshmallow Cookie
You May Also Like
Vanilla & Chocolate Cake/Cupcake Recipe Bundle
Vanilla & Chocolate Cake/Cupcake Recipe Bundle
Vanilla & Chocolate Cake/Cupcake Recipe Bundle
Instant Digital Download
C$19.99
BEST SELLER
The OG Cookie Recipe Bundle
The OG Cookie Recipe Bundle
The OG Cookie Recipe Bundle
Instant Digital Download
C$59.99
Cookie Cake Recipe Bundle
Cookie Cake Recipe Bundle
Cookie Cake Recipe Bundle
Instant Digital Download
C$12.99
  • My Account
  • Track Orders
  • Favorites
  • Shopping Bag
Display prices in:CAD
Skip to main content
Baked by the Lake
Digital Recipes
About
Contact Us
Menu
Baked by the Lake
Terms & ConditionsReport abuse
Made with Ecwid by Lightspeed